Tuesday, October 27, 2009
Wrapping up the September/October reading list
Most of these books that I've read (the Piano Teacher, Auto-da-fe, Mourning Becomes Electra) are about such extraordinary people. Here, I'm not using the word "extraordinary" as one describes superheroes or gods, but as in the sense of being an island amongst people - these characters (Erika Kohut, Kien, Herzog, the Buendias) have festered so long in their isolated world that they are unable to reconcile their perception of the world with reality. It apparently makes for great literature. It's really quite something.
On dust jacket flaps and in book reviews, one often reads about so-and-so being an extraordinary character, and so special ("an extraordinary girl in an ordinary life breaks out into stardom" or "the extraordinary adventures of Becky Sharp") but I always feel a little let down by the description. Those characters still react to situations as I might and think as I might. They don't read while their child is being eaten to death by fire ants. They don't stalk around a consignment store, giving people money so that they don't have to sell their books. They don't turn all of their thousands of books in their bookcases so that the spines face inward as a domestic battle tactic. Good one, Kien.
For a concrete example, take Temperance Brennan on the popular tv show Bones. Not only is she named after my personal favourite knightly virtue, she isn't your average person. Highly intelligent, slightly socially awkward, overly rational and, of course, beautiful, she's really not the girl next door. But, on the extraordinary fictional personage scale, she doesn't hold her own against Kien and the life. Despite her apparent inability to perceive sarcasm or bounds of socially accepted conversation, she still has human emotions. She has friends and shows concern for her coworkers. At times, viewers can still relate to her. If you, however, want to read about someone intelligent, socially awkward, overly rational/idealistic, and is guaranteed to react different from you in every possible situation, then let me refer you to Auto-da-fe.
Rushdie once wrote: "If from speed you get your thrill, take precaution - make your will." Well, if from deviance you get your thrill, read on - but make your will. I'm glad I read on. Now, my first thought when dealing with troublesome cohabitants is an impulse to rearrange all my books in battle position.
Sunday, September 13, 2009
13: The Waste Land and Other Poems
T. S. Eliot, The Waste Land and Other Poems
The first copy of this that I borrowed from the library had more notes in it than the Half-Blood Prince’s potions book. So, I borrowed a second copy, which was less marked up but still contained plenty of marginalia. In the first copy, the person with the pink pen has outlined each section of the poems and several pencil markings have quite insightful comments. I think that it’s interesting to read a book that so many people have read, deciphered and left traces of their days of reading; it gives hints to future readers. I somehow think that margins are meant to be written in and books are meant to be lived in. The physical book shouldn’t be venerated; this is where Kien of Auto-da-fé went wrong. Because Therese put on gloves to read a beaten up old book, Kien thought that her action showed a love and respect for books, when in reality, it should only have showed a courtly love for books, which is easier feigned and rarely genuine. Real love of books reads books to pieces. When the pages are dog-eared, the margins filled with notes and doodles and the spine cracked and broken from use, then we can see that the book is well-loved and thoroughly studied.
Overall, there is a deep sense of dissatisfaction with the world and a preoccupation with living death. The dead people that Eliot portrays are not the peaceful, sleeping dead, entered in the ground and pushing up the daisies. Here, death is that of living folk; people who go through life like zombies, people in loveless marriages holding pointless, unsynchronized conversations every day. Perhaps that is the meaning of the lost generation, who failed to see hope in everyday life. And that poem is so chock full of things. Reference, imagery – all very intellectual and elite. The inscription, which I believe says it all best, is in Latin and Greek. It is about Sibyl, the seer that Aeneas appealed to, who had eternal life but not eternal youth. She is asked what she wants and she says she wants to die. I think that is the spirit of the poem; there is life without “something more” than everyday occurrences and stock phrases and stock feelings and Eliot sees it as a living death. But the inscription, how many people could have deciphered that? And there are so many quotations strewn throughout that he appended the poem with a reference section. I think it tries too hard to be so evasive and mysterious, which has led to an over-analysis and dissection of the poem – at least in the copy I read, scribbled in the margins.
Tuesday, September 8, 2009
11: Auto-da-fe
Elias Canetti, Auto-da-fé (Die Blendung, “The Blinding” in the original German)
Elias Canetti won the Nobel Literature Prize in 1981. The title of C. V. Wedgewood’s English translation refers to the opening quote of Heinrich Heine (“where they burn books, there they will burn men also” or similar) and the auto-da-fés of the Inquisition.
Auto-da-fé is about sinologist Peter Kien who lives in an apartment with his great library of obscure texts. He abhors human interactions and keeps to himself. By some stroke of fortune, he feels himself pressured to marry his ignorant housekeeper, Therese. There, all hell breaks loose. Though Kien is under the illusion that Therese married him out of a reverence for his books or some other silly nonsense, Therese is only interested in his money and when Kien’s illusion is shattered, he is driven from his own home by Therese. He takes up with a dwarf, Fischerle, who dupes him and robs him of his money, after seeing Kien pay people, who have come to a pawn shop to pawn books, to keep their books. The books is satirical and Canetti’s world and characters are so ridiculous and strange that it was hard to read.
It’s hard to read about Therese and Fisherle fooling Kien and robbing him of his peace or his money or both. I do feel bad for Kien, but he is a fool. The only people in that book who were intellectual enough to understand him and to be understood by him are his brother, who tried to cure him, and the little boy who asked him about Mencius, but he shunned them both and drove them both away, preferring, instead, the low, uneducated company of Therese and Fischerle.
The thing is that he cannot understand those simple uneducated people. He makes the same mistake as Carol Kennicott. Because they are simple, he assumes that they are also pure and have the purest motives. But they don’t. They in fact have the easiest motive of all; money. Kien endows them in his mind with all sorts of noble qualities, thoughts and tragedies which they have no conceptions of. Kien's reality in his mind is quite a fine place. The real world and Kien’s perception of it are rarely in sync. When he discovers the discrepancy, he is, understandably, destroyed, following in the manner of the strangeness of all events of this book.
I think “The Blinding” is a better title, even if “Auto-da-fé” sounds as strange and foreign as this book feels. Kien is, in fact, very blind to the reality around him. Indeed, it is hard not to be. Reading this was like being sucked into a nightmarish world, which had retained its ability to reason.